Your Guide to the Best Edgartown Seafood

Edgartown SeafoodHere at Sandpiper Rentals, we know that one of the great parts of taking a seaside vacation on Martha’s Vineyard is the amazingly fresh seafood that’s available to you. There’s nothing quite like enjoying your favorite seafood dish while enjoying the beautiful views that the island boasts. Edgartown is one of the best places on the Vineyard to find seafood that is practically fresh off the boat. There are several Edgartown seafood establishments offering fresh catches in delicious recipes. And many of these restaurants have seaside views that will perfectly complement your dining experience. So whether you just want a quick bite to eat or a more formal sit-down dinner, our favorite Edgartown seafood restaurants will hit the spot.

Where to Enjoy Edgartown Seafood

From casual dining and take-out to fine dining experiences, these Edgartown seafood restaurants are sure to satisfy everyone’s appetite.

  • Atlantic: Atlantic bills its fare as “Martha’s Vineyard Seafood with a Twist!” This fish and chop house has top-notch cuisine and is also a great place to experience some Martha’s Vineyard nightlife. The restaurant’s location is ideal for enjoying a meal while looking out on the water. Their extensive menu features fresh seafood, burgers, pizza, steaks, and chops. House specialties include Steak Tagliata and Crackling Pork Shank. Another dish you should try is the Lobster & Truffle Mac & Cheese. Atlantic is also a good place to go to hear live music in a beautiful atmosphere.
  • Edgartown Seafood: Edgartown Seafood is both a family owned fish market as well as a great take-out restaurant. Their take-out menu includes lobster rolls, fish sandwiches, chowder, and cooked-to-order lobsters. The market carries some of the freshest fish and shellfish on Martha’s Vineyard.
  • The Seafood Shanty: The Seafood Shanty has been a go-to destination for Edgartown seafood for more than fifty years! And with the perfect combination of delicious food and drinks and waterfront views, it’s easy to see why The Seafood Shanty has become a favorite.  Along with New England classics like clam chowder, lobster rolls, crab cakes, and lobster they also offer a menu of superb sushi. Sushi is available by the roll or on platters. Don’t forget to top your meal off with one of their specialty drinks!
  • The Square-Rigger Restaurant: Located on Edgartown Vineyard Haven Road, this Edgartown seafood restaurant has all the classics you crave on the menu. Their full lobster menu includes grilled lobster, boiled lobster, baked and stuffed lobster, a lobster sauté, and Lobster Newburg with sherry sauce over puff pastry. Other favorites on the menu include fresh sea scallops, cod, shrimp, and clams. If someone in your party isn’t in the mood for seafood, they also have a selection of steak, chicken, and lamb chops.

No matter where you decide to get your Edgartown seafood fix, choosing Sandpiper Rentals for your accommodation needs will make your time on Martha’s Vineyard memorable. We have amazing Edgartown rental homes that will be the perfect home-away-from-home while you enjoy all the island has to offer. Whether you want to stay Downtown or in the Katama area, we have the perfect rental for your needs.

Photo: marla-chebby/iStock/Thinkstock

One thought on “Your Guide to the Best Edgartown Seafood”

  1. …and don’t forget Lobster Tales Catering if you’d like a real old fashioned New England Lobster Bake experience! 508-627-5071

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published.